Plea Bargaining Pros and Cons

An explanation of plea bargaining, including the pros and cons.

By , Attorney
Defend your rights. We've helped 95 clients find attorneys today.

There was a problem with the submission. Please refresh the page and try again
Full Name is required
Email is required
Please add a valid Email
Phone Number is required
Please add a valid Phone Number
Zip Code is required
Please add a valid Zip Code
Description is required
By clicking "Find a Lawyer", you agree to the Martindale-Nolo Texting Terms. Martindale-Nolo and up to 5 participating attorneys may contact you on the number you provided for marketing purposes, discuss available services, etc. Messages may be sent using pre-recorded messages, auto-dialer or other automated technology. You are not required to provide consent as a condition of service. Attorneys have the option, but are not required, to send text messages to you. You will receive up to 2 messages per week from Martindale-Nolo. Frequency from attorney may vary. Message and data rates may apply. Your number will be held in accordance with our Privacy Policy.

You should not send any sensitive or confidential information through this site. Any information sent through this site does not create an attorney-client relationship and may not be treated as privileged or confidential. The lawyer or law firm you are contacting is not required to, and may choose not to, accept you as a client. The Internet is not necessarily secure and emails sent through this site could be intercepted or read by third parties.

Plea bargaining refers to the negotiations between prosecutors and defense lawyers on how to resolve criminal charges. Plea bargaining results in defendants' pleading guilty or nolo contendere (a plea in which the defendant does not contest the charges, but which carries the same primary consequences as a guilty plea) in return for a stated sentence, agreement not to request more than a certain sentence, or dropped charges. Judges are sometimes part of the negotiation process as well.

The vast majority of cases are settled by plea bargaining, which can begin as soon as charges are filed and continue right up to the jury's verdict.

Plea Bargains from the Defendant's and Prosecutor's Views: Pros

A bargain has the obvious advantages of certainty and reduction of risk. The defendant avoids the risk that:

  • a trial will uncover evidence that is even more damning (resulting in the possibility of added, harsher charges)
  • the jury will find him guilty, and
  • the judge will "throw the book" at him.

From the prosecutor's point of view, a settled case will clear the trial calendar, leaving room for other cases. It also removes the risk that the defense will convince the jury to acquit or hang. Settled cases result in happy judges, too, because their case loads lessen—prosecutors always benefit when they make judges happy.

Plea Bargains from the Defendant's and Prosecutor's Views: Cons

A defendant who pleads guilty must admit guilt. This person loses the chance to convince the trier of fact, be it a judge or jury, of his lack of guilt. The most seasoned trial attorneys, be they prosecutors or defense attorneys, will be hesitant to tell you that a case is a slam-dunk for conviction. Juries are unpredictable, as are witnesses.

Prosecutors lose a bit, too, when they bargain a case. Victims and the public may be angered at a settlement for a crime they think deserves the full force of the prosecutor's efforts. And when the deal does not include a specified, agreed-upon sentence, the prosecutor may end up unpleasantly surprised when the judge hands down a lenient punishment.

Statutory Limitations on Plea Bargaining

Not every case can be bargained "down." In some instances, where the statute provides for a mandatory minimum sentence, the prosecutor cannot agree to a lighter sentence. For example, statutes proscribing driving under the influence of drugs or alcohol often specify that increased penalties will apply for repeat offenders; and certain assault crimes carry an enhanced sentence when the victim was a child or other protected person. In these situations, the prosecutor may be able to reduce the charges (to reckless driving or a lesser assault, for example). But, without reducing the charges, the prosecutor wouldn't be able to promise a lighter sentence than the minimum specified for the original charge.

Constitutional Limitations on Plea Bargaining

Plea bargaining that attempts to nail down a specific sentence must involve a willing judge for the bargain to be a deal that the defendant can rely on. That's because the sentencing function is uniquely judicial—no prosecutor can authoritatively tell the judge, "This is what the defense and I have agreed will be the sentence." Sometimes, the bargaining will involve the judge from the outset, and when that happens and the judge signs-off on the deal, the sentence is set. But often the deal will involve only a promise that the prosecutor will not ask for a sentence greater than a certain amount. In these cases, there's no guarantee that the judge will follow this recommendation. To protect themselves in these scenarios, defendants often build into the plea the option to withdraw the plea if the judge indicates that he or she will impose a sentence other than the one recommended by the prosecutor. (For more, see Withdrawing a Guilty Plea.)

Practical Limitations

Defendants who plead guilty in exchange for a lesser charge or sentence must still appear before a judge and admit guilt. Judges will conduct an often lengthy "voir dire" (oral examination) of the defendant, asking whether the defendant understands that he or she is giving up the right to trial, to testify, and to call witnesses. The voir dire includes asking defendants if they understand every element of the offense to which they intend to plea, and if they admit each such element. Judges will not accept a guilty plea unless a genuine "Yes" follows each of the judge's questions. Judges conduct these examinations in order to make sure that defendants are well aware of what they are giving up—and in order to ensure that later, a defendant cannot claim that he pleaded in ignorance of the rights that were never explained to him.

Because a plea won't "go down" unless the defendant passes the judge's voir dire, attorneys typically spend a time preparing their clients for this examination. Defendants who are pleading guilty out of expediency, but who resist admitting actual guilt, will have a hard time successfully pleading before a rigorous judge.

DEFEND YOUR RIGHTS
Talk to a Defense attorney
We've helped 95 clients find attorneys today.
There was a problem with the submission. Please refresh the page and try again
Full Name is required
Email is required
Please add a valid Email
Phone Number is required
Please add a valid Phone Number
Zip Code is required
Please add a valid Zip Code
Description is required
By clicking "Find a Lawyer", you agree to the Martindale-Nolo Texting Terms. Martindale-Nolo and up to 5 participating attorneys may contact you on the number you provided for marketing purposes, discuss available services, etc. Messages may be sent using pre-recorded messages, auto-dialer or other automated technology. You are not required to provide consent as a condition of service. Attorneys have the option, but are not required, to send text messages to you. You will receive up to 2 messages per week from Martindale-Nolo. Frequency from attorney may vary. Message and data rates may apply. Your number will be held in accordance with our Privacy Policy.

You should not send any sensitive or confidential information through this site. Any information sent through this site does not create an attorney-client relationship and may not be treated as privileged or confidential. The lawyer or law firm you are contacting is not required to, and may choose not to, accept you as a client. The Internet is not necessarily secure and emails sent through this site could be intercepted or read by third parties.

How It Works

  1. Briefly tell us about your case
  2. Provide your contact information
  3. Choose attorneys to contact you